Hot Topics

Submitted on 11 May 2004 by Derreth Duncan, Manager, Volunteer Services, Thirteen/WNE, New York, NY 10001

Volunteer Managers… The Next Generation
I have the same opinions on the AmeriCorps suggestion as the rest of our tribe but I want to make some additional observations. I have worked with hundreds of student leaders, many did AmeriCorps service before they entered public service. Despite their variety, their similarities are striking. Here’s my list:

• They are highly efficient learners. They had to be to get into and out of the universities they attended.
• They are used to learning environments and organizations.
• They have specific skills – and experience – in project management, team building and leadership development.
• Their management – and leadership – style is often collaborative and non-hierarchical
• As the knowledge workers of the future, they have 21 st Century communications skills; proficient in both print media with its linear reading conventions and internet environments where information is accessed in multiple dimensions.
• They expect diversity in their lives and in their workplace.

How do our jobs match up with their needs, what kind of workplaces do we offer and… They may be better trained and more highly skilled than your current managers.

Are We Ready For Them?
We already know that bad volunteer management practice has consequences. When people have a bad experience, feel their time is wasted and their skills are misused they leave, they don’t come back and they talk about it. Your reputation suffers. The consequences will be similar when we misuse AmeriCorps members but they will also be worse because we run a much graver risk of losing them from public service completely if we treat them badly. Why stay?

This could be a terrific opportunity to influence and mentor future leaders. But we need to think about it because it isn’t a quick fix and it doesn’t come for free.

Submitted on 28Apr2004 by Scott D. Ingram, Director of Programs, Volunteer Center of Southern Arizona
A brilliant, but alas, flawed concept! After several years recruiting, observing, supervising, training, cajoling, counseling up to 60 AmeriCorps members a year, I've determined that the vast variance in the raw material you have to work with and the limits of a one-year term conspire against success in this instance. What we want are "consultants" who have skills, motivation, and credibility. The author is absolutely correct in stating that pre-service training and linking the members to a Volunteer Center would be essential. However, experience shows that the ability to recruit members who want to do this (as opposed to say, direct service mentoring kids) and are qualified/trainable - think business graduates, is limited at best. Finally, what happens in year two? Now you start all over again, low on the left end of the learning curve and entering unknown territory with respect to motivation and credibility. The idea of a Volunteer Consultants group like, for instance, SCORE, is a much more viable in the long run.

Submitted on 15April 2004 by Jayne Cravens, United Nations Volunteers, Germany
I think Steve's idea of placing a team, and all of his other points, are a great idea. At UN Volunteers, we are trying to evolve from just a volunteer placement organization to a volunteer promotion organization -- but our UN Volunteers are experts in engineering, governance, preventing HIV/AIDs, agriculture and education -- not volunteerism or volunteer management. Like AmeriCorps volunteers, training is *desperately* needed if UN Volunteers can act as advocates for volunteerism.

My biggest frustration in reading Susan and Steve's comments -- and everyone else's -- is that I doubt anyone from the Corporation is really listening... what a shame.

Submitted on 12April2004 by Kathleen McCleskey, KM Consulting and Training Connection, Texas, USA
I have conducted training for VISTA and AmeriCorps members for many, many years. Several years ago a PSO (pre-service orientation) was developed for VISTA. There was not one word in it about how to manage volunteers. The EST (early service training) which took place several months into the VISTA’s term of service did have a module on managing volunteers but it was in an “information discovery” format. As a long time advocate, volunteer, practitioner, trainer, and consultant, I did mention “how to’s” about managing volunteers. I felt I had to because VISTA’s were being sent into their communities to recruit volunteers without one word about how to even begin to accomplish that part of their time of service. When I conduct training for AmeriCorps, it is never about managing volunteers but other subject areas.

The preparation for VISTA and AmeriCorps members to set up a volunteer program much less manage one is lacking. Then to add to that many of the program directors have never had a volunteer in their agency and are unable to help these members at all. I have talked to many members and they often feel “set up for failure” unless they have been given resources outside their formal training. For example: join a DOVIA, attend any training they can afford to attend at the local level. Some Volunteer Centers maybe prepared for the role of training in the area of volunteer management and some may not. Then there is the issue of cost which is another article I am sure.

Submitted on 11April2004 by Rob Jackson, Volunteering Development Manager, RNIB, Lincolnshire, England
As Steve mentioned, here in the UK we look set to get BritCorps so enamored of Americorps is our Chancellor Gordon Brown. I think we therefore have an opportunity to learn from the lessons of AmeriCorps and Steve's observations seem, on my limited knowledge of the programme, to both accurately identify the faults and propose some useful improvements.

Our government has thrown £300million at making it easier for people to find out about volunteering but almost nothing into support for volunteer management. BritCorps could go some way to remedying that omission but only if we learn the lessons of AmeriCorps in the USA.

Submitted on 2April2004 by Marnie Goldenberg, Manager for Professional Development in the Voluntary Sector, Volunteer Vancouver British Columbia, Canada
As a person who is dedicated to building the capacity of the voluntary
sector and its volunteer programs, I think Steve's idea is an excellent one for a number of reasons.

First, it acknowledges the need to create short term volunteer opportunities. Secondly, it recognizes the ability of young people to strengthen the sector. Third, it provides an engaging opportunity for people to use all their talents to build something that can have a lasting impact. This is not a one-off project -- future AmeriCorps
participants can continue the consulting work, can evaluate the impact of the work, or can take the work in new directions. One year consultants could focus on volunteer program evaluation, the next on board development. There is an unending supply of opportunity here! My only recommendation: the consulting team needs to set realistic goals when working with organizations over a short period of time. Create opportunities for success so that we build enthusiasm for more system development.

Submitted on 2April2004 by Cara Thenot, Director of Online Publishing, Energize, Inc., Pennsylvania USA
I truly appreciate the previous 2 entries which help dispel a false assumption that all AmeriCorps members are young adults with not very much experience in the field of volunteer management. Some of the concern about AmeriCorps members serving as volunteer managers may come from that assumption. I recently visited the AmeriCorps Web site and discovered that several AmeriCorps programs have no age limit for volunteer applicants.

That being said, the real concern should focus on experience rather
than age, which AmeriCorps can address in recruitment policies for this particular assignment. On their Web site, AmeriCorps states, "Some programs have specific skill requests in certain areas, and others look for a bachelor's degree or a few years of related volunteer/job experience." I don't see the harm in requiring a certain amount of experience managing volunteers AS WELL AS using Steve's suggestions for training to ensure that a volunteer or team is prepared for the challenging task at hand.

Submitted on 2April2004 by Hillary Roberts, Pres., Project Linus NJ, Inc., NJ/USA
Last month's topic had me a bit frustrated for all NPO managers. You most certainly outline well thought out, idea provoking solutions. Consider me recruited.

Submitted on 2April2004 by Kathryn Pursch, Women in Community Service, Seattle, WA
Steve brings up some excellent points about the need for thoughtful structure and pre-service training on volunteer issues as essential components for Americorps members charged with the task of involving volunteers. If Americorps members are focused on sustainability and program development (as VISTAs already do) in addition to the direct service portion of their work as temporary VPMs, then the whole thing might just lend energy and new ideas to our field. I am an Americorps VISTA alum now working in Volunteer Management. . .my Americorps experience led me to my current career. I welcome the opportunity for more people to gain experience in the field, and am excited by Steve's ideas on structured support!

Submitted on 2April2004 by Janet Sharma, Executive Director, Volunteer Center of Bergen County, Hackensack, New Jersey - USA
Janet Sharma is former chair of the Volunteer Center National Network of 350 Volunteer Centers working in partnership with the Points of Light Foundation.
If indeed AmeriCorps members are going to delve full steam into the field of volunteer management, I really like the concept of a team of AmeriCorps members working with a Volunteer Center. The team members could benefit significantly not only from the existing relationships that the Volunteer Center has with a broad range of community and faith-based organizations, but also from the expertise that many Volunteer Centers have in training volunteer program managers. It will be interesting to see how this plays out -- whether the Corporation for National and Community Service will attempt to 'reinvent the wheel' utilizing inexperienced AmeriCorps members in one-on-one situations, or whether CNCS will leverage existing expertise within Volunteer Centers to create a wealth of knowledge that can nurtured and passed along as AmeriCorps members rotate in and out of the team.

Submitted on 2April2004 by Lois, Washington USA
I also am a mid-life AmeriCorps member. The strategies outlined in this article are excellent. From my AmeriCorps experience so far, I know that many VISTAs are already being asked to be temporary volunteer managers--without much direction and with even less preparation or training. I think the article applies to all of AmeriCorps, however. According to the VISTA manual, "The VISTA's role is focused toward mobilizing community resources and increasing the capacity of the target community to solve its own problems." As you can see, even if a VISTA's project is not specifically identified as "volunteer management," the full scope of the mission can only be accomplished through volunteers. We need all the help we can get!

Submitted on 1April2004 by Barbara. Volunteer Manager/Habitat for Humanity, MI
Absolutely! Americorps members need training about volunteer management. That is a must. I started at a Habitat affiliate as a AmeriCorps member at the ripe age of 46. We are not all youth. Thank goodness, I had experience working with as well as being a volunteer myself. I had absolutely no training through AmeriCorps. I think a team of AmeriCorps members to promote volunteerism in a community as well as design a recruitment, retention and reward system is a great idea.

Share Your Response